Navigating the Path of Writing: Short Stories vs Novels for Beginners

For a writer just starting out, the decision between writing short stories and novels can be a challenging one, especially when high anxiety and perfectionism are part of the equation. The merits of each format offer different paths for honing your craft and building confidence, and choosing the right one depends largely on your personal goals and inclinations.

Short stories present an appealing option for many beginners due to their brevity and the relatively quick turnaround from start to finish. The idea of completing a piece in a shorter time frame can be particularly motivating, providing a sense of accomplishment and progress that is crucial for overcoming feelings of being a "serial quitter" or a "non-starter." Each finished short story represents a victory, an opportunity to practice the elements of storytelling on a smaller scale, and a chance to explore different styles and genres without the long-term commitment required by a novel. This can be especially beneficial for managing anxiety, as the stakes feel lower and the effort more contained.

However, if your passion lies in the realm of novels and the stories that keep you up at night are all of novel-length, it’s important to honor that passion. Writing what truly excites you can help maintain your motivation and engagement, which is critical when tackling the substantial challenge of writing a novel. While the prospect of completing a novel can be daunting, breaking it down into smaller, manageable chunks—much like the way you might approach a series of short stories—can make the process less overwhelming. Set small, achievable goals for yourself, such as writing a single scene or chapter at a time, and celebrate each milestone.

Balancing the two approaches could be your best path forward. You might begin by experimenting with short stories to gain confidence and build your writing routine. Use these shorter works to practice key skills like character development, dialogue, and plot structure. Meanwhile, keep a journal or outline for your novel ideas, allowing yourself to slowly develop them without the pressure of immediate completion. This dual approach lets you work on your craft in a manageable way while still nurturing your larger, more ambitious projects.

Additionally, consider using short stories as a stepping stone to your novel. You could write stories set in the same world or featuring the same characters as your novel ideas, helping you develop a deeper understanding of your narrative and its elements. This technique can make the transition to writing a full-length novel feel more natural and less intimidating.

Remember, the goal at this stage is learning and gaining confidence, not necessarily publication. Give yourself permission to write imperfectly, to experiment, and to find joy in the process rather than solely in the finished product. Over time, as you become more comfortable with your writing practice, the idea of tackling a novel may feel less overwhelming.

Buy: The Psychology Workbook for Writers

In summary, while short stories can offer quick wins and valuable practice, your passion for novel-length storytelling shouldn't be ignored. By balancing both forms and focusing on small, achievable goals, you can build your confidence and skills, ultimately paving the way for successful novel writing in the future. Embrace the journey, be kind to yourself, and remember that every word you write brings you one step closer to your dream.

Remember, writing is a personal journey, and there is no one-size-fits-all approach. Find what works best for you and take it one step at a time. Your stories are worth telling, and with perseverance and patience, you will find your path as a writer.

Buy: Crafting a Masterpiece

Happy writing!